The only problem Denis Villeneuve had to overcome while making Dune: Messiah

SUMMARY

• Dune: Messiah's adaptation presents challenges due to its lack of action, focus on politics, and a darker, more introspective story.

• Dune: The Third Part may struggle with audience expectations for a blockbuster finale, without a high-octane performance.

• Villeneuve faces the task of portraying the evil arc of Paul Atreides in a politically sensitive situation, which may cause controversy.

The future adapter of Dune: Messiah may be the most anticipated sci-fi project of the future. However, director Denis Villeneuve faces major obstacles to overcome in order to bring his grand vision to life – perhaps more than any other. Dune movies or TV shows.

The one that is said to be unfilmable Dune The story had to be divided into two parts, and many details were omitted or omitted. Therefore, the reason for making an adapter is clear Dune Messiah it can be the same or even more difficult. Frank Herbert's sequel to his early science fiction shows a particular difficulty. It's not just the sheer size and sheer length, but also the design and content, which can be difficult to translate to the big screen.

Why not Dune Messiah Difficulty Adapting?

Less action, more politics

Dune: Messiah is likely to complete a famous trilogy that can be compared to classics such as Star wars, Lord of the Ringsand many others. However, the problem of use Dune Messiah because the source of the third film is that it may not fit with the studio's current vision of concluding the trilogy. Compared to the first Part, Dune: Part Two relied heavily on action over dialogue, so it was only natural that audiences would expect a climactic battle in the third film. But fans of the book know that's not the case.

What happens to the Dune Messiah?

Dune Messiah 12 years after Paul Atreides became emperor. Over 60 billion people died during his reign, yet Paul still verified it through his vision. His power grows so far beyond control that groups like the Bene Gesserit and the Spacing Guild are forced to conspire to drive him out.

The lack of visibility of Dune Messiah

Issues for concluding trilogy

The history of Dune Messiah is a dark and brooding affair. Compared to the first book, which clearly defined the villains and dramatic moments like Paul riding sand, this sequel is less action-packed. Messiah It focuses on the conspiracies in the palace, the conflict within Paul, and his descent into tyranny. There is no place or no place for a piece of furniture. Even the war is discussed as something that happens in the background, and only the aftermath is felt in the background.

This will be a challenge for the audience who expect a high performance after that Part Two. Instead of a blockbuster movie, they will get a more meditative story about corruption, sacrifice and the dangers of absolute power. If it happens to be lukewarm Dune: Prophecy taught us anything, but this slow and heavy sound does not carry the impact of Warner Bros.

Featuring Paul Atreides' Troubled Arc

Director warns against hero worship

Another big challenge Villeneuve and his writing team had to overcome was how to portray Paul Atreides' evil arc in Dune: Messiah. Dune: Part Two has shown Timothée Chalamet's character starting to let power consume him. As for the original Dune is like a cautionary tale against hero worship, wrote Frank Herbert Dune Messiah to destroy any misconception about Paul as a hero. He discussed this in a 1980 article titled Dune Genesis:

So that's part of my theme for Dune: Don't leave all critical thinking to the people in power, no matter how good those people are. Beneath the hero's tomb you will find people making mistakes. Serious problems arise when human error occurs on the scale of a hero.

Potential political issues

This sequel must fully commit to portraying Paul Atreides as a ruthless ruler who kills billions of people and justifies his actions in the name of a greater cause. In fact, there are important conversations with Stilgar in the book where Paul refers to real-life historical figures like Genghis Khan and Adolf Hitler to make his point. It is likely that such an event will not accurately interpret the current social, political and cultural situation. even if Dune: Prophecy avoided controversy by not naming the Butlerian Jihad as it is called in the book, instead calling the movement Machine War.

It is unlikely that the producers will fully deal with the dark side of Paul Atreides' character. On the other hand, to weaken or remove them from the public will diminish their value as anti-heroes. While most gray actors are acceptable to modern audiences, Paul's journey from self-proclaimed savior to murderous leader may be too extreme for many to understand.

Dune: The Messiah could still be a masterpiece

The risk is worth the reward

Not every big movie needs to feature a big fight during the third act. Even though Dune Messiah since it is mostly a political and religious story, there is still room for high stakes and hostile threats. Moreover, the difficulty of matching Paul's character development continues to prove its importance. If the arc is played out perfectly, it could become a cinematic feat of subverting the superhero archetype on this scale.

The best way to achieve this is to depict the war accurately — to show parts of it, instead of starting the story after it has happened, as in the books. Villeneuve has done this in previous films by expanding the elements of Dune which Herbert wrote down or transferred to the background. Peter Jackson did something similar Lord of the Ringswhere he took small details from the books and turned them into epic pieces.

If anyone can pull it off, it has to be Denis Villeneuve. the Blade Runner 2049 The director could still choose to take his creativity and introduce new elements of the Holy War to bring it to life. Some consider the Dune Messiah story as an epilogue Dunewhile others see it as an integral part. However, it's up to Villeneuve to turn it into a signature franchise finale that balances action and philosophy.