Although it may be pushing seven years, we still find new and strange secrets in the world of fans Red Dead Redemption 2. In their quest to create the most realistic and dominant open world to date, Rockstar has spared no expense. The result is a game full of quirky and memorable characters, beautiful natural scenery, and strange and mysterious mysteries that remain unsolved to this day.
Most of these secrets are hidden in plain sight, although many players may miss them if they don't take the time to look for them. This is especially true in the city of Pleasance. Between the rolling plains of Scarlett Meadows and the shocking mud of Bayou Nwa, the player may go through this ghost town dozens of times and not stop to investigate it further. But taking the time to get off the horse and look around reveals one of the darkest stories Red Dead Redemption 2.

related
Red Dead Redemption 2: The Mysteries of New Austin Explained
Although it opens after the end of the main story, New Austin holds nostalgic easter eggs for Red Dead Redemption 2 players willing to find them.
Nearly seven years later, fun remains one of RDR2's most haunting mysteries
As seen in the game, Pleasance is a long-abandoned town on the banks of Bayou Nwa; echoes of a town where the simple inhabitants of Lemoyne lived. There is an air of unsettling mystery about the ghost town, but recent discoveries Red Dead Redemption 2The subreddit had fans seeing the entire city in a new light.
Apparently, the residents of Pleasance never left, but rather the town's cemetery. A few cemeteries dot the already overcrowded cemetery, but one impressive element of the cemetery is a great reason to explore the city deeper. Each gravestone has the same date of death listed; everyone in Pleasance died that day. The causes of death were gunshots and stabbings, but whatever happened on September 17, 1883 was nothing short of a massacre.
What happened to the fun in Red Dead Redemption 2?
According to the incident of Red Dead Redemption 2 in 1899, the Pleasance was abandoned for almost 16 years. Anyone who follows true crime content will attest that piecing together a case that is cold is almost impossible, and there really aren't any concrete answers to what happened in 1883. But Rockstar has left many fans to to combine a few possible series. what is happening.
The first clue to note about the Pleasance mystery is the sequence of events. A dilapidated sign on the edge of town welcomes visitors to the town and states that it was founded in August 1883. The city lasted maybe a month before it was completely destroyed. Whatever happened that led to the murder hit the community hard and fast, leading to the first possible theory surrounding the fall of Pleasance: disease.
In several places around the city there are messages written on the doors and windows. Ominous warnings were written around the city that read “Filthy with Sin”, “Sick with Sin!” and “Stop the plague!” giving the impression that the town was abandoned due to disease, but the violence of the townspeople revealed that this was not the case. A new disease could have spread through the city and the afflicted were killed to prevent the spread of the disease, or mercy killed if the disease was really bad. But as with all mysteries there Red Dead Redemption 2things may not be as they seem.
Is Pleasance a town of devil worshippers?
Most importantly, the church in the city does not have a distinctive religious icon. There are no crosses, religious symbols, or anything that could be a sign of established religion anywhere in the city. It can be very strange considering the era and setting, and Rockstar has proven time and time again its commitment to historical detail and making the game as realistic as possible. If these tags are removed it is for a reason.
Some believe that this, along with the many references to sin in the graffiti, point to some sort of occult practice such as devil worship at Pleasance. It's certainly not the first time Red Dead series that tended to have supernatural elements. Proponents of the occult theory say that the city destroyed itself with ritual violence, or that outsiders from the nearby city of Rhodes came in and disposed of the bad people. a spirit that dared to approach his land.
Other theories surrounding the city have implications for the Night Folk, as the city is on the border with their territory, but these theories don't hold much water. While such acts of brutality are in keeping with the Night Folk's view of the game, the small details of the executions do not fit their MO. The Night Folk are rarely seen using guns in any encounter, favoring silent weapons like bows and knives. Also, the presence of corpses to bury is very different from the behavior displayed by the Night Folk, who are seen carrying the corpses of their victims to create gruesome carnage across the swamp.
It will never be known exactly what happened to the people of Pleasance or why it only took a month for the town to become a ghost town. And that is the beauty of the world created by Rockstar. In real life, mysteries are not always solved and tied up with neat little bows. Sometimes, the best one can hope for is to find a satisfactory theory that explains the lingering question. Even for a game that strives for realism and immersion, this can be one of the most realistic things. Red Dead Redemption 2.